---

---

Here is a list of questions that were frequently asked in the past Top Picks Workshops. The list will be updated by appending new questions at the end of the list.

FAQ 1: Are papers that appeared in journals eligible?

Answer: Yes, they are eligible for presentation and discussion in Top Picks Workshop. If they are selected as a Top Pick, they will be recognized but a publication in IEEE D&T may not be feasible.

FAQ 2: Can I not present at the workshop and be considered for the top pick?

Answer: No, presentation at the workshop is mandatory to be considered for the top pick.

FAQ 3: Can I submit multiple papers? Is there a limit on the number of papers submitted/nominated per author?

Answer: Yes, you can submit/nominate multiple papers as long as they are eligible. There is no limit on the submissions you can make.

FAQ  4: Is there any format requirement for the 2-page nomination letter?

Answer: Yes. The submission should follow the IEEE TCAD format. The following link has the information on the submission style: https://ieee-ceda.org/publication/tcad-paper-submissions

FAQ 5: How can I help?

Answer: There are many ways that you can help the Top Picks Workshop. First, nominate a paper or encourage your colleagues to submit. Second, volunteer to serve as a program committee member. Third, register and participate the workshop and actively involve in the discussion. Fourth, volunteer to serve as a reviewer for the D&T special section papers of the Top Picks. For volunteer opportunities, email the workshop co-chairs.

FAQ 6: What are the rubrics for review?

Answer:

The final selection will be based on: 

– Intellectual impact- Scientific rigor 

– Industry impact

– Reproducible

– Open-source usage

– How does the work change the belief in community